It all started thre
e years back when ordering a butterscotch shake during a lunch break at a softball tournament. Some of the guys couldn’t believe butterscotch would ever be chosen over caramel. My personal view was the opposite. This sparked a minor debate ending with me exclaiming “let’s find out what’s better!” About a month later Jen and I hosted a blind “bring your favorite butterscotch/caramel tasting”. A total of six people actually showed . :-)
There were two butterscotch, three caramel, and one butterscotch/caramel toppings to taste. Each was presented in a ramekin with a small scoop of vanilla ice cream. If memory serves, we only rated taste. In the end neither butterscotch nor caramel dominated. It was the ingenious combination of the two, Mrs. Richardson's Butterscotch Caramel Dessert Topping, that won by a wide margin. There aren’t any pictures from this 2007 event, but we did require a secret handshake to get into the house. One of which was caught on hidden camera.
Sorry Scribner’s. Time to change that secret butt slap up now that the secret’s out. :-)
Since this 2007 event, we’ve had three other fun tastings; cheddar cheeses, ketchup, and most recently, root beer. We don’t have pictures from the cheese tasting, but Cougar Gold and Tillamook Vintage White Extra Sharp took home first and second respectively.
The ketchup and root beer tastings were documented more thoroughly. Details coming soon.



